Mate Sound the Pump...
  • Home
    • Copper transfer plates
    • Dixon partnerships
    • North Shields Pottery partnerships
    • Seaham Pottery ownerships
    • London impressed mark
    • Fake over-painted items
    • Reproductions
    • References
    • Links
    • Exchange
  • Early plaques (pre-1845)
    • C, C & Co
    • Carr
    • Dawson
    • Dixon, Austin & Co
    • Fell
    • Maling (c1830–1840)
    • Maling attr (c1840-45)
    • Moore & Co
    • Newbottle
    • Scott
    • Sheriff Hill
    • Staffordshire
    • Turpin
    • Tyneside
    • Wallace
    • Unidentified
    • Relief plaques
  • Religious
    • Prepare to meet thy god – 1
    • Prepare to meet thy god – 2
    • Thou god seest me
    • Praise ye the lord
    • Behold god...
    • For/But man dieth...
    • Rejoice in the lord
    • God is love
    • Other scripture verses
    • John Wesley
    • Adam Clarke
    • Charles Wesley hymns
  • Maritime
    • May peace and plenty
    • Common ships
    • Less common ships
    • Rare ships
    • Maritime verses
    • Mariner's arms/compass
    • Other maritime
  • Miscellaneous
    • Plaques with hand-painted text
    • Poetic verses
    • Emblems and armorials
    • Portraits
    • Cast iron bridge of the Wear
    • Landscapes
    • The Bottle
    • Our Dumb Companions
    • Other pictorial plaques
  • Blog
  • Home
    • Copper transfer plates
    • Dixon partnerships
    • North Shields Pottery partnerships
    • Seaham Pottery ownerships
    • London impressed mark
    • Fake over-painted items
    • Reproductions
    • References
    • Links
    • Exchange
  • Early plaques (pre-1845)
    • C, C & Co
    • Carr
    • Dawson
    • Dixon, Austin & Co
    • Fell
    • Maling (c1830–1840)
    • Maling attr (c1840-45)
    • Moore & Co
    • Newbottle
    • Scott
    • Sheriff Hill
    • Staffordshire
    • Turpin
    • Tyneside
    • Wallace
    • Unidentified
    • Relief plaques
  • Religious
    • Prepare to meet thy god – 1
    • Prepare to meet thy god – 2
    • Thou god seest me
    • Praise ye the lord
    • Behold god...
    • For/But man dieth...
    • Rejoice in the lord
    • God is love
    • Other scripture verses
    • John Wesley
    • Adam Clarke
    • Charles Wesley hymns
  • Maritime
    • May peace and plenty
    • Common ships
    • Less common ships
    • Rare ships
    • Maritime verses
    • Mariner's arms/compass
    • Other maritime
  • Miscellaneous
    • Plaques with hand-painted text
    • Poetic verses
    • Emblems and armorials
    • Portraits
    • Cast iron bridge of the Wear
    • Landscapes
    • The Bottle
    • Our Dumb Companions
    • Other pictorial plaques
  • Blog
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

10/12/2010 0 Comments

Acceptable restoration or fake?

Myrna Schkolne has debated how much repair or restoration should be acceptable to collectors (see her blog piece 'A perfect 9'). I suppose much depends on why you collect. For plaque collectors, it's quite feasible to build up a collection of perfect examples, for relatively little money. For those like me, however, who want to assemble as much knowledge, as quickly as possible, a hairline crack or even a missing corner, won't put them off a rare plaque. Who knows? It might be 10 years before another comes along. But one thing I think we all agree on, is that an item covered in heavy modern over-painting has next to no appeal.

Over the last few years I've been following the progress of an eBay seller, 1079edmund, who purchased rubbed or plain items and embellished them with fake over-painting.  See my March 2010 blog postings and the Fake over-painted items page for the full story.  Despite a large spread in the Antiques Trade Gazette and many complaints to eBay, 1079edmund has continued to trade.  

A few months ago he changed his eBay identity to toby-20.  Take a look -- the same feedback history, the same private listing auctions, the same photographic backgrounds, the same appalling spelling, and the same location, Wales. It's the same eBay account with a different name. Until now, the items he's listed, under his new identity, appeared untampered with. So who was I to knock a man who'd turned over a new leaf?

But over the last few weeks, toby-20 has listed two plaques I've felt unsure about.  The first, a typical 'Eastern scene' (see below), looked to have perfectly original enamelling to the central transfer.  Unusually, the outer borders are pink rather than copper lustre. But that's possible for late items stamped 'Dixon Co'. However, the irregular-looking corners might suggest over-painted damage, and I don't recall ever seeing an outer border quite so purple. You'll have to make up your own mind about this one, because I'm not sure.
Picture
The second plaque, currently listed on eBay, looks all wrong. What should be dark and rich copper lustre in the corners is flat and brown. The pink lustre on these 'Carr' plaques is usually very deep, almost purple. Compare toby-20's plaque to the plaque with real lustre (second picture).
Picture
Picture
In fact, the only place I've seen this combination of colours is on 1079edmund's faked plaques (see below). So if the lustre was rubbed or faded, and the seller decided to over-paint 60% of its front surface, has this plaque been acceptably restored?  Note that the seller doesn't list any restoration in his latest listing.
Picture
My frustration here isn't with a petty criminal, who can't resist the compulsion to smear antique objects with household paint. It's eBay who are at fault. They choose to ignore complaints from buyers, after the event, because the seller has 100% positive feedback rating. Despite a marketing pledge to tackle antiques fraud, every 'improvement' to eBay's site over the last few years appears to be designed to protect their revenues. Come on eBay, isn't it about time you put your buyers first?

If you are sure that an eBay item looks wrong, click on 'Report item'. Then select 'Fraudulent listings' and 'You suspect a listing is fraudulent (you didn't bid)'. In the above case I gave the description as 'Fake over-painting, item listed as restoration free'.  

Though my faith in eBay is rock bottom, if enough people complain they'll surely have to do something.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Stephen Smith lives in London, and is always happy to hear from other collectors. If you have an interesting collection of plaques, and are based in the UK, he will photograph them for you. Free advice given regarding selling and dispersal of a collection, or to those wishing to start one. Just get in touch...

    matesoundthepump@yahoo.co.uk 
     

    Archives

    February 2022
    August 2020
    June 2020
    September 2018
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    October 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010

    Acknowledgements

    This website is indebted to collectors, dealers and enthusiasts who have shared their knowledge or photos. In particular: Ian Holmes, Stephen Duckworth, Dick Henrywood, Norman Lowe, Keith Lovell, Donald H Ryan, Harold Crowder, Jack and Joyce Cockerill, Myrna Schkolne, Elinor Penna, Ian Sharp, Shauna Gregg at the Sunderland Museum, Keith Bell, Martyn Edgell, and Liz Denton.
Proudly powered by Weebly